CFP Executive Director Bill Hancock said there remains a strong consensus to expand the four-team field among the management committee, comprised of the 10 major college football conference commissioners and Notre Dame’s athletic director.
But how and when? A proposed 12-team model remains at the heart of the discussions and there is still hope it can be implemented for the 2024 stagione. How teams would qualify and be selected are topics still under discussion.
“I thought there was a chance we’d get to the end today,” Grande 12 Commissioner Bob Bowlsby said. “We didn’t and there were good appropriate reasons why we didn’t. There are people in the room that are differently situated and they therefore have different perspectives. And they were healthy discussions. I think we made good progress, but we aren’t done.”
There is no firm date for the next meeting, but there is one scheduled for January around the College Football Playoff championship game in Indianapolis.
Mountain West Commissioner Craig Thompson said there are still some who would rather expand only to eight teams. Others are adamant eight won’t work.
“I was part of a group that brought forward a recommendation of six conference champions and six best remaining teams — or you can stay at four,” said Southeastern Conference Commissioner Greg Sankey, one of four members of the subcommittee that worked for two years on the 12-team model put forth nearly six months ago.
Where do things stand with that original proposal?
“Bene, it’s certainly not been approved,” Sankey said. “Altrimenti, we wouldn’t be having this conversation today.”
The seven-hour meeting at a hotel at the Dallas-Fort Worth Airport was the sixth in-person gathering of the management committee since the 12-team proposal was unveiled in June.
The commissioners from the Big Ten, Atlantic Coast Conference and Pac-12, all relatively new to playoff talks, were skeptical of the process from the start and became even more leery of how quickly it was moving toward 12 after it was revealed the Southeastern Conference would be adding Oklahoma and Texas to the league in the next few years.
Big Ten Commissioner Kevin Warren, ACC Commissioner Jim Phillips and Pac-12 Commissioner George Kliavkoff did not speak with reporters after Wednesday’s meeting.
Those three had pushed to revisit the possibility of expansion to only eight teams, though the obstacles to getting agreement on eight were plentiful.
Da allora, the road to expansion has become bumpy.
“I wish we had finished in September,” said Bowlsby, who was also a member of the expansion subcommittee with Sankey, Thompson and Notre Dame AD Jack Swarbrick.
At the last meeting in November, the possibility was raised of tweaking the 12-team proposal to ensure Power Five conference champions have automatic qualification, while only the top-ranked champion from the other five conferences would be guaranteed a spot.
That was met with strong opposition from American Athletic Conference Commissioner Mike Aresco.
Hancock tried to place a deadline on the process in early October, saying consensus from the commissioners needed to come in the next three or four months.
“We were directed to develop a format and if possible, implement early,” Sankey said. “So is it still possible to implement early? I think so.”
The presidential oversight committee must approve whatever proposal the management committee lands on. The university presidents and chancellors usually attend the CFP meeting around the championship game, which is set for Jan. 10 in Indianapolis.
If the commissioners can’t agree on a new model soon, Hancock has said the CFP would continue as is with four teams through the end of the current 12-year television rights deal that expires after the 2025 stagione. E adesso?
“I wouldn’t say there’s any hard deadline at this point,” Bowlsby said.
“This was a hard day, and I think all of us are tired and we came away from it with the feeling that we made enough progress to keep moving forward and that the expansion of the playoff, we’re very near consensus that we believe it ought to get larger,” Bowlsby said. “And there are details to work out.”