Ex-Epstein employee on experiencing misconduct by Maxwell: 'Never'

“Never,” Cimberly Espinosa, 55, responded when asked if she ever saw Maxwell or Epstein “engaged in any misbehavior.”

Espinosa also testified about seeing a key accuser in the case — who testified for the government as “Jane” to protect her privacy — visiting Epstein’s New York City office on Madison Avenue “a few times” in the late 1990s. She said Jane’s mother had told workers she was Epstein’s goddaughter.

Ghislaine Maxwell, left, sits at the defense table before the start of her trial with defense attorney Bobbi Sternheim, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in New York. 

Ghislaine Maxwell, left, sits at the defense table before the start of her trial with defense attorney Bobbi Sternheim, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in New York.  (Elizabeth Williams via AP)

GHISLAINE MAXWELL TRIAL: A BREAKDOWN OF THE CASE

Because of that, “she was treated with utmost respect,” Espinosa said. Jane’s interactions with Epstein gave her the impression “it was a loving relationship,” she added.

Espinosa told the jury in federal court in Manhattan she assisted Maxwell in managing Epstein’s multiple high-end properties between 1996 and 2002.

“I looked up to her very much,” she said.

When defense attorney Christian Everdell finished his questioning, Assistant U.S. Attorney Lara Pomerantz tried to convince jurors that Espinosa was an irrelevant witness by asking her only whether she had ever worked at any of Epstein’s homes.

When Espinosa said she had not, Pomerantz said she had no other questions.

The defense case began after the jury heard four women detail accusations, including Jane, that they were teens when they became victims of a sex-abuse scheme devised by Maxwell and Epstein. The British socialite’s attorneys are expected to make their case that Maxwell isn’t the one to blame.

In this courtroom sketch, defense attorney Bobbi Sternheim, left, questions expert witness Elizabeth Loftus, right, as Judge Alison Nathan listens, on the bench at center, during the Ghislaine Maxwell sex abuse trial, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in New York. 

In this courtroom sketch, defense attorney Bobbi Sternheim, left, questions expert witness Elizabeth Loftus, right, as Judge Alison Nathan listens, on the bench at center, during the Ghislaine Maxwell sex abuse trial, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in New York.  (AP Photo/Elizabeth Williams)

GHISLAINE MAXWELL TRIAL STARK REMINDER THAT AMERICA NEEDS TO DO MORE TO FIGHT CHILD SEX TRAFFICKING

The government’s case lasted only two weeks and the defense case could last just two days. Both sides streamlined their witness lists without revealing why, making the trial end well short of an original six-week estimate.

The start of the defense case has already sparked the usual speculation about whether the high-profile defendant will take the witness stand in her own defense — a gamble that is almost never taken. Either way, U.S. District Judge Alison Nathan will have to receive direct confirmation from Maxwell about her decision before the defense can rest.

Maxwell, 59, has pleaded not guilty to charges she acted as Epstein’s chief enabler, recruiting and grooming young girls for him to abuse during sexual massages.

Defense attorney Christian Everdell, (left at podium,) questions the first defense witness Cimberly Espinosa, Ghislaine Maxwell's former assistant as Judge Alison Nathan, center, listens from the bench, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in New York. 

Defense attorney Christian Everdell, (left at podium,) questions the first defense witness Cimberly Espinosa, Ghislaine Maxwell’s former assistant as Judge Alison Nathan, center, listens from the bench, Thursday, Dec. 16, 2021, in New York.  (Elizabeth Williams via AP)

GHISLAINE MAXWELL TRIAL: DEFENSE COULD CALL MORE WITNESSES THAN PROSECUTION

Maxwell was once Epstein’s girlfriend before becoming a trusted employee. Witnesses testified the pair exploited them between 1994 and 2004 at Epstein’s homes, including an estate in Palm Beach, Florida; his posh Manhattan townhouse; and a Santa Fe, New Mexico, ranch.

The defense has insisted that Maxwell is being made a scapegoat for alleged sex crimes by Epstein, who killed himself in jail in 2019. Her lawyers have sought to show that the accusers exaggerated Maxwell’s involvement at the behest of lawyers seeking payouts for the women from civil claims against the Epstein estate.

The defense also tried Thursday to show that the recollections by the women are flawed. To support that argument, they relied on testimony from cognitive psychologist Elizabeth Loftus, who has for decades studied false, repressed and unreliable memories. Loftus also testified last year at Harvey Weinstein’s New York City rape trial.

Maxwell’s lawyers are trying to cast doubts about the women’s allegations after using cross-examination to highlight inconsistencies in some of their accounts. In some cases, the encounters the women were recalling happened more than two decades ago.

As memories fade, Loftus said, people become more vulnerable to “post-event” information, including media reports that can distort what they remember.

People can grow attached to false memories in a way that “they can be confident about them, they can be emotional about them, even when they’re false,” she added.

Comments are closed.