A holiday centered on gift-giving and indulgences arrived in an industrializing Britain at a time when deprivation and want were everywhere
. No story captures that contrast more than
“A Christmas Carol.
” Charles Dickens wrote the tale in
1843, and it would play a pivotal role in popularizing Christmas celebrations
. But it did so through a tale of painful inequality
, informed in part by Dickens’s angst over children put to work in the country’s mines and factories
. There was wealthy miser Ebenezer Scrooge
, impoverished clerk Bob Cratchit and his son Tiny Tim
, desperately in need of health care his family cannot afford
Spirits intercede not with a tale of Christianity but humanity, filtered through capitalism. Scrooge has the means to do good, and the good he does brings him joy as well: a tidy fable of philanthropy.
如果 “A Christmas Carol” centered on philanthropy, the tales that came after put sacrifice at the center of Christmas, especially for those with little to give. 在 “Little Women,” written by Louisa May Alcott in the late 1860s, the March family gives up its Christmas breakfast to feed a much poorer family that lives nearby. When they arrive home, they find an even bigger feast awaiting them, provided by a wealthy neighbor.
While the Marches do not go without
, the family in O
“The Gift of the Magi
,” a Christmas short story from
1905, has no neighboring philanthropist on hand
. 所以, the couple sells the things that matter most to them — the wife her hair
, the husband his watch — to give a gift that will be treasured by the other
: a now-useless set of combs and a watch chain
, testaments to their sacrifice and love
It’s a theme repeated in the Christmas movie classic “It’s a Wonderful Life,” whose main character George Bailey believes he’s worth more dead than alive, until an angel shows him how much his life has mattered to the people around him, who ultimately rally to his side to bail him out of financial trouble.
While deprivation shaped these Christmas tales
, a worry over commercialism inflected
“How the Grinch Stole Christmas
,” written by Theodore
“博士. 苏斯” Geisel
. Rather than worrying about children in factories and the brutality of industrial labor
, 博士. Seuss has his eye on the burgeoning consumerism of the United States after World War II
, worried that the crush of toys and postwar prosperity could corrode not just the meaning of Christmas
, but a deeper sense of purpose and community in American life
The story has its own Scrooge-like protagonist, one who attempts to upend the joyous holiday by stealing all its trappings, from the gifts to the stockings to the roast beast and all its trimmings — only to find his victims were perfectly happy gathering for a pared-down Christmas. The takeaway here is also a tidy one: “Maybe Christmas, he thought, doesn’t come from a store. Maybe Christmas, 也许, means a little bit more.”
The challenge this Christmas is that both consumption and community have been curtailed for many Americans. Church services have been scaled back or canceled. Singing carols has been marked as a particularly effective way to spread the virus. The warm communion of families and friends, which Christmas fables assure us makes up for sparse stockings and scaled-back presents, has been largely rerouted to Zoom and FaceTime.
While we can be grateful for the technology that brings us together, it still feels like deprivation: the loss of handshakes and hugs, of game nights and dancing, of the rush from house to house that shapes so many of our holiday seasons.
It turns out there are Christmas aids for that longing, 太. “I’ll Be Home for Christmas,” Bing Crosby’s 1943 歌曲, may seem to promise a Yuletide reunion, but its final phrase — “if only in my dreams” — reveals that such a gathering isn’t possible. Written during World II, it was sung from the perspective of a soldier stuck overseas, not knowing when he’d see his family again.
We live in that same limbo this year, and as hard as this holiday will be for many of the people who celebrate it, it helps to recall that Christmas has long been a holiday capacious enough for the bitter as well as the sweet, the painful as well as the joyful. And if anything, it is a holiday that invites us to reflect on how we can ease the misery of others, and in doing so, lighten our own.